In a world where generosity is generally performative, how do we help our kids cultivate the kind of generosity that doesn’t seek glory or recognition? How do we teach and model the countercultural secrecy of giving?
The Mandate
In Matthew 6:3-4, we read, But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing, so that your giving may be in secret. And your Father who sees in secret will reward you.
This is a wildly countercultural idea. It is a forgotten instruction that flies in the face of everything we see on social media. But here is the good news. The holidays are traditionally a generous time of year. Thirty percent of all charitable giving happens between Thanksgiving and New Year’s. Christians take the lead in that generosity. We give generously because Christ withholds no good thing from us (Psalm 84:11) and has generously given us His all. We give to be a blessing and not for public praise. When it comes to our generosity in this world that loves the publicity of good works, what is the solution for Christian parents? Here are three practical ways to get your family engaged in the blessing of secret generosity.
The Methods
There are three main things we can give in secret: praise, provisions and presents. Praise, in the form of an encouraging note or letter of appreciation, is an incredible gift. Your pastor, the middle school teacher, a neighbor: this gift works for anyone. Perhaps you’ve appreciated how friendly your neighbor is or how carefully they shovel the snow from their sidewalk because they know your kids walk home from the bus stop. Did something in your pastor’s sermon stir your heart or cause you to think more deeply? Are you simply impressed that your child’s teacher wrangles the attention of that many kids, day in and day out, with excellence and care? That appreciation can be quickly expressed in a note (don’t sign it), attached to a candy bar, and secretly delivered.
Provisions supply the practical needs we find around us. If you’re not sure what needs exist in your neighborhood or community, ask your pastor or the principal at your child’s school. Assess the needs and what your family might be able to do to provide for them. Insist on your anonymity. Can you send a grocery delivery order to a single mom or mail her a gas card with no return address? Your family might not be able to meet all the needs you encounter, and that’s okay. Pray for God’s provision for the rest, trusting that just as He has stirred your heart to action, He will also stir the hearts of others.
Presents are just for fun and to share more of the love of Christ. Maybe this will take the form of cookies or a basket of fruit delivered to your neighbors with a cheery, unsigned note. Could you get up early with your kids to shovel the snow for elderly neighbors before they wake up, or drop off doughnuts for the staff at a local nursing home on Thanksgiving morning to thank them for working on the holiday? The ideas are endless. That’s why we need an intentional plan and our children’s involvement.
The Mission
It’s time to call a family meeting. For something this important, we want our kids’ opinions and input. Plus, no one loves the idea of a secret mission more than a child.
Explain to your kids that your family is on a secret mission before Christmas. Begin by describing the Bible’s instructions for giving. You might want to include the above verses from Matthew 6 or perhaps 2 Corinthians 9:7, which talks about giving financial support and relief to the poor and suffering among believers, reminding us that Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver. Ask your kids why they think people publicly post their giving to social media. Talk about the feelings of affirmation that recognition and attention can give, and how the praise of others is temporary but the favor and blessings of God are irreplaceable.
Then describe the mission to your kids: to bless and encourage as many people in secret as possible (and as is practical for your family). Ask your kids to name the mission. It needs a code name. Maybe you’ll pick one neighbor or a few needy families in the community. Maybe your own finances are tight and acts of service and appreciative notes will be your game plan. Let your kids brainstorm ideas. Most likely, they’ll have some creative ones and some that will actually work.
Take notes as you go. Write down names. Chances are, your kids may have tuned in to some needs you’ve missed. If you’re stumped on names, consult your pastor or the principal of the local school. Explain that your family would like to give anonymously to meet a need during the holiday season. Offer to allow the recipient to remain anonymous to your family to respect their privacy.
Assess the needs that you learn about or know about in your community. Present the ones that are feasible to your kids. Allow them to be as involved as possible. Perhaps this is a shopping trip for a Christmas gift for an elderly neighbor or clicking the order button online that sends the makings of a meal to a family in need. Maybe this is small hands meticulously drawing a Christmas tree on a card and adding way too much glitter. Let your kids take ownership, use their allowance, sneak a package onto a neighbor’s porch (under your watchful eye), or do the act of service in secret alongside you. This is something they will never forget.
The Meaning
I grew up in a single-parent household, and my family often had desperate needs. I might be able to tell you the names of a few people who helped my family, but mostly, I recall with great affection how God supplied so many of my needs through people who didn’t care to have their names known. When we give in secret, we remove the praise from ourselves. We don’t deserve it, and it doesn’t belong to us. Our giving in secret lets it settle on the One who deserves all praise and glory. When we teach our kids that the blessings of God for obedience and generosity are irreplaceable, they learn to reflect His goodness to the world, rather than seeking glory for themselves.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved.